Why Students Struggle with Reading and How Inference Skills Can Fix It

As educators and parents, we've all encountered this scenario. A student reads a passage fluently, pronouncing every word correctly, yet struggles to answer comprehension questions. They can tell you what happened in the story, but can't explain why a character made a particular decision or predict what might happen next. This isn't a reading problem in the traditional sense. It's an inference problem, and research shows it affects students from primary school through to secondary education.

The Research Behind Reading ComprehensionChallenges

Decades of educational research consistently identify inferential thinking as the most challenging aspect of reading comprehension across all year levels. Whilst the difficulty manifests differently at various developmental stages, the fundamental challenge remains constant throughout a student's educational journey.

Landmark studies by Cain and Oakhill – Understanding and Teaching Reading Comprehension demonstrated that inference-making ability is the strongest predictor of reading comprehension success. Their longitudinal research tracked students over multiple years and found that children who struggled with inference in primary school continued to face comprehension difficulties in secondary school unless they received targeted intervention.

A comprehensive literature review conducted by Anne Kispal – Effective Teaching of Inference Skills for Reading examined decades of research on reading comprehension. It concluded that inference is "one of the most challenging aspects of reading comprehension" across all educational levels. Critically, the research found that inference skills require explicit teaching and don't develop naturally for many students, regardless of how much they read.

Data from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) in the United States reveals a persistent pattern. Students consistently score 15 to 25 percent lower on inferential questions compared to literal recall questions. This performance gap exists across all tested grade levels, from Year 4 through Year12, demonstrating that inference challenges aren't limited to younger students.

Understanding What Makes Inference Difficult

Inferential reading requires students to "read between the lines" by combining textual clues with background knowledge to draw logical conclusions. Unlike literal comprehension, which involves locating explicitly stated information, inference demands several simultaneous cognitive processes.

According to research by Oakhill, Cain, and Bryant (2003), successful inference requires students to hold multiple pieces of textual information in working memory, retrieve relevant background knowledge, integrate text clues with prior knowledge, and formulate logical conclusions. This cognitive load proves challenging at every stage of development.

Consider this example suitable for various year levels. A secondary English text might describe a character repeatedly checking their phone, pacing, and struggling to focus on conversations. Students must infer that the character feels anxious or worried, even though the text does not explicitly state this emotion. Similarly, a primary school passage might describe storm clouds gathering and animals seeking shelter, requiring students to infer that rain is coming soon. Both scenarios demand the same fundamental skill at age-appropriate complexity levels.

The Critical Transition Points

Whilst inference challenges persist throughout schooling, research identifies specific transition points where these difficulties become most apparent and consequential.

The Year 4 Turning Point

Educational researchers Chall and Jacobs (2003) – The Classic Study on Poor Children’s Fourth-Grade Slump documented what they termed the "Fourth-Grade Slump," a well-established phenomenon in which many students' reading comprehension suddenly plateaus or declines around the fourth grade. At this stage, texts shift from simple narratives to more complex expository structures. Vocabulary becomes more sophisticated and domain-specific. Most significantly, students transition from "learning to read" to "reading to learn".

This transition exposes students whose inference skills are underdeveloped. Children who previously appeared to be capable readers suddenly struggle because the texts they encounter demand higher-level inferential thinking.

The Secondary School Challenge

The inference challenge doesn't disappear in secondary school; it evolves. As students progress throughYears 7 to 12, they encounter increasingly sophisticated texts across multiple disciplines. Science texts require causal inferences about experimental results. Historical passages require inferences about the motivations and decisions of historical figures. Literature studies require students

Research by Perfetti, Landi and Oakhill(2005) identified different types of inferences that challenge students at various levels. Local coherence inferences connect information between adjacent sentences. Global coherence inferences integrate information across paragraphs or entire chapters. Bridging inferences fills gaps that the author intentionally left. Elaborative inferences require going beyond the text to understand deeper meanings.

Secondary students must master all these inference types across multiple subject areas simultaneously, making inference a foundational skill for academic success.

Types of Inferences and Their Difficulty Levels

Understanding which inferences prove most challenging helps educators and parents provide targeted support that is appropriately tailored. Research by Graesser, Singer and Trabasso (1994) established a hierarchy of inference difficulty that remains relevant across all year levels. Causal inferences, where students understand why events occurred without explicit explanation, prove most demanding. Character motivation inferences follow, requiring students to determine why people acted in particular ways. Predictive inferences, where students anticipate outcomes based on textual clues, rank as moderately difficult.Emotional state inferences, identifying feelings from context, are somewhat easier. Pronoun resolution, determining what pronouns refer to, represents the least challenging inference type. This hierarchy applies across develop mental stages, though text complexity and required background knowledge naturally increase with each year level.

Why Students Continue Struggling Despite Years of Reading

Many educators and parents express frustration when students who've been reading for years still struggle with inferential comprehension. Several research-identified factors explainthis persistent challenge.

Metacognitive Awareness Deficits

Van Keer's research (2004)found that students across primary and secondary levels often don't recognise when information is implied rather than stated. They lack awareness of their own comprehension breakdowns, don't spontaneously employ fix-up strategies when confused, and may not realise they need to make an inference to understand the text.

Background Knowledge Gaps

Anderson and Pearson's influential research (1984) established that successful inference requires the activation of relevant prior knowledge.Students often possess relevant knowledge but fail to connect it to texts spontaneously. Additionally, students from varied backgrounds have different knowledge bases, creating comprehension gaps that widen over time.

Instructional Gaps

Duke and Pearson's research(2002) revealed that many curricula focus heavily on literal comprehension across all year levels. Inference instruction, when it occurs, is often implicit rather than explicit. Students receive insufficient practice with guided inference-making, and teachers may assume students will naturally develop these skills through reading exposure.

The Cross-Curricular Impact

Inference difficulties don't remain confined to English or literacy classes. They affect performance across the entire curriculum.

In Science: Students must infer cause-and-effect relationships from experimental data, understand implied relationships between variables, and draw conclusions from observations.

In Mathematics, Word problems require inferring what operations to perform based on contextual clues. Students must infer relationships between mathematical concepts and real-world applications.

In History and SocialStudies: Understanding historical events requires inferring motivations, causes, and consequences that primary sources may not explicitly state.

In Literature, Advanced literary analysis depends entirely on inference, from identifying themes to understanding symbolism and authorial intent.

This cross-curricular impact means that inference difficulties compound over time, affecting overall academic achievement rather than just reading scores.

How NotesEdu Strengthens Inference Skills Across Year Levels

Strong inference skills are the invisible engine behind reading comprehension, exam success, and critical thinking. Yet, from early primary through to secondary school, inference remains one of the most challenging skills for students to master and high-quality, structured resources are scarce.

If these skills aren’t built early, students risk falling behind in reading, problem-solving, and exam performance as texts become more complex each year.

NotesEdu closes this gap by providing comprehensive, developmentally sequenced resources and free monthly materials to support every child’s learning journey, whether they’re just beginning or preparing for high-stakes exams.

Tailored Resources for Every Year Level

Unlike generic comprehension worksheets, NotesEdu’s materials are differentiated by year level to match students’ cognitive and language development:

• Primary Years: Students build foundational inference skills through age-appropriate narratives, clear     visuals, and guided questioning.
• Secondary Years: Resources shift to multi-paragraph passages across various genres and subject areas, mirroring the academic texts students encounter in their coursework.

This structured progression ensures students don’t plateau. Each stage builds upon the last, allowing students to develop confidence before tackling complex reasoning tasks.

Question Design and Explicit Strategy Instruction

Every reading passage includes multiple carefully designed inferential questions. These progress from identifying emotional states and pronoun resolution through to tackling predictive, character motivation, and causal inferences—the skills most demanded by advanced texts and exams.

What makes NotesEdu different is the step-by-step reasoning model included with every question. Instead of just marking answers right or wrong, NotesEdu:

• Highlights textual clues within the passage
• Explains how to connect these clues with existing knowledge
• Demonstrates how to combine both to reach logical conclusions

This explicit modelling mirrors proven “think-aloud” strategies, making expert reading processes visible and learnable for all students.

Targeted Insight for Parents and Teachers

For busy teachers and parents, knowing exactly where a student is struggling saves time and frustration. NotesEdu’s diagnostic tools break down performance by inference type, revealing whether a student needs help with emotional understanding, causal reasoning, or broader text integration.

• Teachers can use this data to provide targeted support in diverse classrooms, ensuring no student is left behind.
• Parents gain clear insights to support their child at home, focusing their efforts where they matter     most.

This targeted approach means every student receives the proper support at the right time.

Why Inference Skills Matter?

Inference skills are not just for English tests. They underpin success across:

• NAPLAN and numeracy sections, where students must interpret word problems and data
• Selective School and Scholarship exams, which require decoding complex passages quickly and accurately
• Every day, academic learning, from science investigations to history analysis

Students with strong inference skills work more efficiently, think more clearly, and apply their knowledge across various subjects. Those without them often spend valuable time just trying to understand the question — widening the achievement gap year after year.

Beyond exams, inference skills form the foundation for critical thinking, media literacy, and decision-making in adult life. The earlier these skills are taught explicitly, the stronger their long-term impact will be.

NotesEdu’s FREE Reading Comprehension Resources

Many schools and families don’t have easy access to high-quality supplementary materials. That’s whyNotesEdu offers free resources designed to build inference skills systematically:

With NotesEdu’s resources, explicit instruction, and free monthly materials, parents and teachers can equip students with the tools they need to become confident, strategic readers who not only read words but also understand them deeply.

Click the links below today to access the free resources:

• FREE Inference Worksheets

• FREE Reading Comprehension Tests

• FREE Inference Quiz

IMPORTANT: Make Sure You Never Miss Free Learning Materials

Many parents tell us they missed out on our monthly free resources because they never saw our emails, which were sitting unnoticed in their spam or junk folder. By the time they checked, they had already missed valuable worksheets, multiple-choice questions, quizzes, and exam-aligned materials their child could have used. To prevent this from happening to you, follow the simple steps below to make sure our emails land in your inbox every time. Don’t let a spam filter be the reason your child misses essential learning support and upcoming free resources.

What You Should Do to Receive All NotesEdu’s Email with Free Resources

1. Add NotesEdu Email Address  to Their Contacts / Address Book
   “Please add contact@notesedu.com.au to your contacts to make sure you continue receiving our updates.”

2. Check Spam or Junk Folder Regularly
   Sometimes, the first email lands in spam. If you find it there, drag it into your Inbox or click ‘Not Spam’ to ensure you don’t miss future resources.

3. Mark the Email as  “Important” or “Star”  (Gmail users)
   If you use Gmail, please star contact@notesedu.com.au  or mark it as ‘Important’ so future updates arrive straight to your inbox.”

How You Can Adjust Your Spam Settings

Gmail

• Go to the Spam folder, open the legitimate email, and click “Not spam.”
• To prevent future filtering:
   
  1. Click the three dots (⋮) on the email.
   
  2. Select “Filter messages like this.”
   
  3. Click “Create filter.”
   
  4. Tick “Never send it to Spam” and “Always mark as important.”

Outlook / Hotmail

• Go to the Junk Email folder, select the message, and click “Not junk.”
• Add contact@notesedu.com.au to your Safe Senders List:
   
  • Go to Settings → View all Outlook settings   → Mail  → Junk email
   
  • Under Safe senders and domains, click Add and enter your domain (e.g.,      www.notesedu.com.au).

Yahoo Mail

• Open the Spam folder, select the message, and click “Not Spam.”
• Add the email to your contacts

Note:
You can unsubscribe from NotesEdu’s list if you don’t want to receive our FREE resources

‍